Annabel Pizza

Discover delicious pizza and satisfying appetizers at Annabel Pizza in Sussex, NJ. Enjoy a wide menu variety including buffalo chicken pie, mozz sticks, garlic knots, calamari, wings, and more. Friendly staff and great flavors await you!

Welcome to Annabel Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Annabel Pizza
Annabel Pizza
Annabel Pizza
Annabel Pizza

Nestled on East Main Street in Sussex, NJ, Annabel Pizza serves up mouthwatering dishes that keep locals coming back. Known for its friendly staff and vibrant atmosphere, the restaurant radiates an inviting charm. Each bite brings a burst of flavor, from the signature buffalo chicken pie to their famously cheesy mozzarella sticks. It's a place where pizza lovers unite, offering a wide variety of pizzas, calzones, and Italian favorites.

Families, friends, and food enthusiasts can indulge in a unique dining experience that caters to all tastes, ensuring everyone leaves satisfied. With a commitment to quality and community, Annabel Pizza creates a welcoming hub in Sussex.

Location & Contact

Address

70 E Main St #72, Sussex, NJ 07461, United States

Phone

+1 973-875-1886

About

Annabel Pizza
Annabel Pizza
Annabel Pizza
Annabel Pizza

Annabel Pizza represents the heart of Sussex’s dining scene. Customers rave about their buffalo chicken pie, which combines spicy buffalo sauce with cheese and chicken on a perfectly baked crust, embodying the perfect comfort food. The extensive menu features 196 dishes, ensuring that everyone finds something they love. Popular offerings extend beyond pizza; the wrap section includes a delicious BBQ chicken wrap, perfect for those seeking savory flavors in a different format.

The commitment to variety doesn't end there.

With appetizers like zucchini sticks and bruschetta paired with a diverse salad lineup, Annabel Pizza caters to healthy preferences as well. Not to mention, the restaurant features a special kids' menu that delights the younger crowd. Annabel Pizza's ability to cater to families speaks volumes about their community presence and family-friendly atmosphere.

The unique aspect of dining at Annabel Pizza is how it fosters a sense of community. Many regulars visit not just for the food, but for the friendly interactions with staff and fellow diners.

Local events often circulate within the restaurant, creating a lively hub where neighbors gather to share meals and stories. Annabel Pizza embodies the essence of Sussex—familiar, friendly, and delicious. It's the go-to spot for pizza cravings, celebrations, and everything in between.

Work Hours

  • Sunday10:30 AM-9 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday10:30 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday10:30 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday10:30 AM-9 PM
  • Friday10:30 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday10:30 AM-9 PM

Annabel Pizza boasts an extensive menu that caters to diverse cravings. From classic pizzas and pasta dishes to unique offerings like the taco slice and shrimp fra diavolo, there's something for everyone. The restaurant showcases a variety of appetizers, including crispy garlic knots and tantalizing calamari, perfect for sharing. For those on the go, lunch menu options feature hearty choices like baked penne with ricotta and tortellini alfredo.

The vibrant, family-friendly environment enhances the dining experience.

Tuesdays at 6 PM see maximum capacity, highlighting the local love for this spot. For quieter visits, peak dining hours reveal the best times. Lunchtime typically peaks on Thursdays, while dinner rushes make Tuesdays exceptional. This understanding of busy periods helps diners plan their visits for ultimate enjoyment.

Annabel Pizza

The exterior of Annabel Pizza is charming and approachable, inviting passersby to step inside. Located at 70 E Main St, it captures the essence of a classic pizzeria, adorned with casual decor that promotes a warm ambiance. Seating options allow for both indoor comfort and outdoor dining on pleasant days, enhancing the community feel.

The vibrant blue signage stands out, drawing attention and creating a welcoming atmosphere. The inviting vibe pairs perfectly with the friendly staff interaction. This restaurant embodies a local secret where delicious food meets a rooted community spirit.

Customer Reviews

So good and everyone in the family loves it. The pizza taste so good, the mozzarella sticks are gooey and have flavor but not over seasoned. The garlic knots are a instant family favorite. Really enjoyed it thank you!!

A
Amanda

Have had pizza here a number of times, always tasty. Tonight we tried the arroz con pollo....WOW!! So delicious, I'll be ordering this weekly!! Always friendly service as well.

J
Jenny H.

Absolutely fye. Very kind customer service, extremely fresh and crispy pies.

D
David D.

I'm a Brooklyn /Staten Island transplant. I grew up having great pizza, and this place has damn good pizza. Also don't sleep on their quesadillas!!!!! I miss a lot of types of food, but thanks to Annabelles, pizza is not one of them!

S
Six V.

Just in the area for the evening. I ordered the Calamari and marinara, and the Chicken Cacciatore. The portions were enormous, and the food amazing. Worth the 6 1/2 hour drive just for dinner. 5/5 would do it again.

J
Jack C.

Best Penne Ala Vodka I've ever had, get it with chicken cutlets and exra mozzarella. I have 4 children aged 5-9 who are picky eaters but they eat every bit when I get this dish. It's 20 dollars for it exactly how I like it and it feeds my family of 6.

J
James M.